Information about crossexamining witnesses if you go to supreme court without a lawyer, plus sample questions to ask. Cross exam the trial courts discretion to limit cross examination must be exercised carefully. It is important that laws and regulations are promulgated in order to avoid a state of lawlessness, hence the need to explore the indian law, as well as, peruse through the cross examination process in india. Order of examinations witnesses shall be first examinedin chief, then if the adverse party so desires cross examined, then if the party calling him so desires reexamined. Cliffe dekker hofmeyr clearcut evidence in a notso.
Even if you suffer from lack of experience, you will shine out. Like a weapon, it must be treated with respect and understanding. Law, viewers see the hero annihilate a witness on cross. Eliciting positive facts known to the witness that help your case or damage. It is preceded by direct examination in ireland, the united kingdom, australia, canada, south africa, india and pakistan known as examination in chief and may be followed by a redirect re examination in ireland, england, scotland, australia, canada, south africa, india, hong kong, and pakistan. Tense cross examination with police officer the trial. Court examples of examinationinchief, cross examination, re. Mahoney excerpted from relentless criminal crossexamination i. On 14 july 2006, prior to the commencement of the prosecutions casein chief, the trial chamber issued an order concerning guidelines on. Aug 17, 2018 court examples of examination in chief, cross examination, re examination and leading questions theory of abrogation. It is hard to anticipate what questions may arise since re examination is dependent on the questions asked in cross examination but the expert should understand why he is being. K slideshare uses cookies to improve functionality and performance, and to provide you with relevant advertising. The objects of crossexamination of a nonexpert fact witness include the following. Plainly that can only benefit the cross examiner, who follows you.
The subject of crossexamination is one of vital importance in the conduct of law cases because only it has the power to sift the truth from falsehood. Although cross examination can be the part of trial that is the most fun for experienced trial lawyers, preparing good cross examination takes a lot of thought and hard work. Sc issues directions on examination of witnesses in. When the lawyer for the plaintiff or the government has finished questioning a witness, the lawyer for the defendant may then cross examine the witness. Tips from a according to at least one judge, most lawyers do a good job in their opening statements, direct examinations, and closing argument, but never learn the art of cross. This section does not deal with the admissibility of proof, but simply establish that a witness shall first be examined in chief, then cross examined and lastly re examined. The legal purpose of a plaintiff or prosecution case in chief is to. Including examination in chief, cross examination, and re examination, founded on the art of winning cases. How to cross examine a witness in an australian court by stephen owenconway qc the object of cross examination 1. Many lawyers launch forth like lemmings jumping off a cliff and crossexamine witnesses without asking the question. You indicate the point you wish to make and put it to the witness. It can be your best friend or your worst enemy if handled incorrectly. Cross examination is an opportunity for the defense attorney to question the prosecutions witnesses during a trial.
Thus, at all levels of the witness testimony, from examination in chief to cross examination to re examination, a diligent effort should be made to gain as much from the witness as possible and to test all that the witness has said, especially with cooperative witnesses. Examination, crossexamination, and redirect examination. The examination of witnesses will usually be done in three stages. Introduction crossexamination is a weapon, an effective weapon if handled correctly and a dangerous weapon if not. Minter ellison rudd watts witex witness competition tutorial 3. A cross examination that simply repeats evidencein chief is a serious misjudgment.
The procedure of recording the evidence of a witness in chief in respect of civil. The art of examinationsinchief and more canadian lawyer. Examination in chief is the first examination after the witness has been sworn or affirmed. Hence one has to be cautious with the questions put forward. Cross examination is generally limited to questioning only on matters that were raised during direct examination. Crossexamination questions should be limited to those which reveal information. Oct 17, 2011 mastering the art of cross examination. Court examples of examination in chief, cross examination, re examination and leading questions theory of abrogation. Crossexamination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. Sample questions to ask when crossexamining witnesses at a. The examination of a witness by the party who calls him shall be called his examination in chief. Preparation for re examination part of your briefing process should be an explanation of the role of re examination and some practice re examination questions. Jan 06, 2012 it should be remembered that the justice should not be defeated by the improper cross examination. After the examination in chief the opposite party shall be called to examine the witness.
Examination of witnesses in criminal proceedingsforensic medicine by visnu. It also gives the extent to which examination in chief, cross examination and re examination may go. So expert a witness had he become that chief justice van. Preparing for examinationinchief of the expert thomson rogers. If the evidence is damaging to your case, why repeat it.
The dictionary part 2, 22 tell us that reference in the act to cross examination. In this stage the party calling a witness, or counsel on his behalf, will seek to elicit evidence that supports his version of the facts. Including examination in chief, cross examination, and re examination. Cross examination by the defense asks the jury to question what was done procedurally during the stop and arrest, to challenge the validity of scientific tests or to doubt the law enforcement officers competency or even integrity. Once you have examined your witness in chief, the other side cross examines your witness. Stephen owenconway qc how to crossexamine a witness in. Examination of witnesses since the parties have a right to crossexamine the opponents witnesses, you must arrange for your witnesses to testify at the trial. Dec 28, 2016 the subject of cross examination is one of vital importance in the conduct of law cases because only it has the power to sift the truth from falsehood. Cross examining complainants in sexual assault proceedings public defenders criminal law conference 2009 paper by belinda rigg, public defender 1. Cross examination may be more exciting and closing argument more eloquent, but it is the direct examination of your own witnesses that will determine whether the jurors hear, understand, and remember the facts upon which your. Before conducting the cross examination of an expert witness, the criminal defense attorney must become an expert in forensic evidence as well as the basic principals of forensics. Leading questions therefore are used in cross examination. Following are sample transcripts that include the states direct examination as well the defense attorneys cross examination of state experts. Normally, examination in chief and cross examination are made in the same day unless allowed to be withheld with the court for some other date.
In law, crossexamination is the interrogation of a witness called by ones opponent. On cross examination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. Examinationinchief meaning in the cambridge english. Cross examination is usually preceded by examination in chief and is followed by re examination.
The defense lawyer should prepare himself for cross examination in advance. The objects of cross examination are to elicit favourable admissions or concessions from the witness. The relevant sections are section 6 to section 166 of the evidence act. Examination in chief is not an opportunity to take the witness through all the points that will be put in cross examination. I try to become almost invisible once the witness is beginning to tell their story. The examination in chief must indirectly counter all the rebutting or all probably questions which may crop out of the cross examination. This questioning of witnesses, whether on direct or cross examination, is an art which. Stephen owenconway qc how to crossexamine a witness in an. Additionally, leading questions are allowed during a partys case in chief. Essentially, it consists of breaking down your cross examination into distinct chapters consisting of the points and subpoints that you want to make for your cross examination. Crossexamination is the process of questioning an adverse party or witness. So examination in chief is an exercise in suppressing your enthusiasm and intervening as little as possible. The questioning of witnesses, which generally falls into three stages known as examination in chief, cross examination, and re examination, is central to the english adversary system of justice.
Rather, if the opposing party required that witness for cross examination, the next involvement of the particular witness would be to attend for cross examination and, possibly, re examination. A party is not entitled to split its case by introducing new facts or opinion during re examination that should have been raised in chief and which were not the subject of cross examination. Sample questions to ask when crossexamining witnesses at. On cross, the attorney should be asking questions that develop the defenses theory of the case theory of the case. Anyone who learns the rules can become a master of the art of crossexamination. This is when you try to heal the wounds that were opened up in cross examination. Sc issues directions on examination of witnesses in criminal. Most important, re examination is strictly restricted to matters that arose at cross examination.
In law, cross examination is the interrogation of a witness called by ones opponent. It should be remembered that the justice should not be defeated by the improper cross examination. The case of filipetti 1984 a crim r 335, for example, may provide guidance in not only giving advice and seeking instructions from a client, but will also enable an advocate to pursue a theme or an issue within cross examination. Stephen owenconway qc how to crossexamine a witness. So often now, an advocate starts his cross examination by dredging through the evidence already given in chief. Chapter x of evidence act 1872, deals with examination and cross examination of witnesses before court of law. Differences between examinationinchief and crossexamination. Leading questions may be asked during cross examination. Cross examination is a dangerous foray behind enemy lines. The direct examination or examinationinchief is one stage in the process of adducing. Differences between examination in chief and cross examination.
Examination of witnesses in criminal proceedings visnu. This chapter focuses on the first stage, examination in chief. The importance of proper examinationsin chief is present in all cases obviously, but in some cases is even more important when the opposing party may not call any evidence and you do not get a chance to cross examine opposing witnesses. Principles, custody, motor vehicle stops and searches, drug. Next to examinationinchief nothing is more important, or difficult in advocacy than crossexamination. An obvious example is the law pertaining to possession in drug matters.
Cross examination is where you get to question the other sides witness. For example, fighting the canada revenue agency in a tax court case. The supreme court of north carolina consistently refers to the range of cross examination as very broad. My own perspective on crossexamination has recently broadened. The re examination must be restricted to matters that were covered during the cross examination. According to section 7 of the indian evidence act, the examination of a witness by the adverse party shall be called his cross examination. One of the purposes of cross examination is to asking questions regarding what the witness has stated in the examination in chief and the answer is the reply by the witness to the question put by the advocate.
Court examples of examinationinchief, cross examination. The objects of crossexamination are to elicit favourable admissions or concessions from the witness. Crossexamination legal definition of crossexamination. Tense crossexamination with police officer the trial. According to section 7 of the indian evidence act, the examination of a witness by the adverse party shall be called his crossexamination. Utilize openended questions for the important parts of the story. During a trial, your cross examination of the opposing counsels witness is an opportunity to make him or her appear unreliable. Before conducting the cross examination of an expert witness, the criminal defense attorney must become an expert in forensic evidence as. Brunt many years ago is said to have remarked, any lawyer who attempts to crossexamine dr. On the same day, after the examination in chief of cw 1narayanan was conducted, an application under section 2312 of the cr. If you do it well, you will win your cases, time and again. The rules of the game cross examination is the litigators greatest weapon, but properly playing the game requires knowledge of the rules and maximum preparation.
And lawyers love to share war stories about how they destroyed a witness on cross. Crossexamination of arresting officer principles, custody, motor vehicle stops and searches, drug cases, search warrants, and searches incident to arrests by kevin j. The questioning of a witness or party during a trial, hearing, or deposition by the party opposing the one who asked the person to testify in order to evaluate the truth of that persons testimony, to develop the testimony further, or to accomplish any other objective. It is a province of a party by whom the witness is called to examine him in chief for the purpose of eliciting from the witness all the material facts within his knowledge which tend to prove the partys case. Crossexamination the interrogation of a witness called by ones opponent. This paper will discuss a number of provisions under the evidence act 1995 that deal with the use of documents, during both cross examination and examination in chief, in criminal proceedings. Evidence the use of documents in crossexamination and. But the essential principles are largely preserved. The prosecutors crossexamination can be an effective. That underlies the suggestion that both the examination inchief and cross examination of children should take place before trial. The witness will give a full account of what he knows about the case. This article first appeared in the octla gavel, fall 2010. If you continue browsing the site, you agree to the use of cookies on this website. Crossexamination scope and limitations subsections b and c of rule 611 specifically address two issues related to the presentation of evidence the scope of crossexamination and the use of leading questions.
Cross examination takes place immediately after direct examination, and is conducted from behind counsel table, or from the podium. Effective crossexamination is a critical part of any criminal trial. Sample crossexamination transcripts criminal defense wiki. The rules about cross examination arent as strict as they are for direct examination when you question your own witnesses. Where in cross examination of a witness, nothing appears suspicious, the evidence of the witness has to be believed. In deposition, cross examine the witness to summarize and lock in her testimony before trial. Final point to note many witnesses come out of giving evidence feeling like they have not had a chance to have their say, but have just been subject to cross examination. Mar 28, 2011 the importance of proper examinations in chief is present in all cases obviously, but in some cases is even more important when the opposing party may not call any evidence and you do not get a chance to cross examine opposing witnesses. Crossexamining complainants in sexual assault proceedings. On crossexamination, however, it is usually impossible to rehearse, so you will have to rely on meticulous preparation. For more trial advocacy tips that will help you persuade. May 21, 2017 a tense cross examination with a police officer is held during this fictional murder trial. Section 7 tells about examination in chief and cross examination of a witnesses.
Effective cross examination can make the difference between winning and losing a trial. The chapter method of organizing cross examination is a widely used and commonly accepted method of organizing cross examination. Cross examination is an effective way for the defense to present evidence by using government witnesses. Crossexamination by the defense asks the jury to question what was done procedurally during the stop and arrest, to challenge the validity of scientific tests or to doubt the law enforcement officers competency or even integrity. Evidence act the evidence national uniform legislation act has quite a lot to say about cross examination which i will come to. Differences between examination inchief and cross examination.
In cross examination you do not want the witness to tell the story. Both subsections establish limits within which a trial judge should exercise discretion in maintaining control and order. On direct examination, witnesses are controlled through preparation and rehearsal. The usual practice is for you to call your client first, but it is worth remembering that, as counsel in the matter, you have a discretion when it comes to the order in which witnesses are called. Order regarding the sequence of crossexamination by the. But cases are usually won by presenting the evidence in your case in chief. Successful cross examinations capture the attention of the jury and judge and expose the. After this the party 12 section 7 of the evidence act.
57 787 1358 446 235 580 119 1561 123 986 1001 498 1493 16 435 775 596 1005 1448 1595 1040 1548 770 106 485 374 1500 611 34 385 545 877 1553 1421 1117 1383 896 685 427 1083 1389 500 624